2023 年的期刊文章 · 第 10 页

共 1511 篇,按发表时间排,新的在前,每页 40 篇。这一页是 2023-08-20 到 2023-08-01。

按期刊、按主题看 →

第 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 页

SiM Clinical Trials Bayesian Methods · 发表于 2023-08-20

Selection of a statistical analysis method for the Glasgow Outcome Scale‐Extended endpoint for estimating the probability of favorable outcome in future severe TBI clinical trials

Yu Wang, Sharon D. Yeatts, Renee' H. Martin, Robert Silbergleit, Gaylan L. Rockswold, William G. Barsan, Frederick K. Korley, Sarah Rockswold, Byron J. Gajewski

摘要

The Glasgow outcome scale‐extended (GOS‐E), an ordinal scale measure, is often selected as the endpoint for clinical trials of traumatic brain injury (TBI). Traditionally, GOS‐E is analyzed as a fixed dichotomy with favorable outcome defined as GOS‐E ≥ 5 and unfavorable outcome as GOS‐E < 5. More recent studies have defined favorable vs unfavorable outcome utilizing a sliding dichotomy of the GOS‐E that defines a favorable outcome as better than a subject's predicted prognosis at baseline. Both dichotomous approaches result in loss of statistical and clinical information. To improve on power, Yeatts et al proposed a sliding scoring of the GOS‐E as the distance from the cutoff for favorable/unfavorable outcomes, and therefore used more information found in the original GOS‐E to estimate the probability of favorable outcome. We used data from a published TBI trial to explore the ramifications to trial operating characteristics by analyzing the sliding scoring of the GOS‐E as either dichotomous, continuous, or ordinal. We illustrated a connection between the ordinal data and time‐to‐event (TTE) data to allow use of Bayesian software that utilizes TTE‐based modeling. The simulation results showed that the continuous method with continuity correction offers higher power and lower mean squared error for estimating the probability of favorable outcome compared to the dichotomous method, and similar power but higher precision compared to the ordinal method. Therefore, we recommended that future severe TBI clinical trials consider analyzing the sliding scoring of the GOS‐E endpoint as continuous with continuity correction.

SiM Clinical Trials Bayesian Methods Causal Inference · 发表于 2023-08-20

Bayesian design and analysis of two‐arm cluster randomized trials using assurance

Kevin J. Wilson

摘要

We consider the design of a two‐arm superiority cluster randomized controlled trial (RCT) with a continuous outcome. We detail Bayesian inference for the analysis of the trial using a linear mixed‐effects model. The treatment is compared to control using the posterior distribution for the treatment effect. We develop the form of the assurance to choose the sample size based on this analysis, and its evaluation using a two loop Monte Carlo sampling scheme. We assess the proposed approach, considering the effect of different forms of prior distribution, and the number of Monte Carlo samples needed in both loops for accurate determination of the assurance and sample size. Based on this assessment, we provide general advice on each of these choices. We apply the approach to the choice of sample size for a cluster RCT into poststroke incontinence, and compare the resulting sample size to that from assurance based on a Wald test for the treatment effect. The Bayesian approach to design and analysis developed in this article can offer advantages in terms of an increase in the robustness of the chosen sample size to parameter mis‐specification and reduced sample sizes if prior information indicates the treatment effect is likely to be larger than the minimal clinically important difference.

SiM Longitudinal Data Nonparametric & Semiparametric · 发表于 2023-08-20

A threshold longitudinal Tobit quantile regression model for identification of treatment‐sensitive subgroups based on interval‐bounded longitudinal measurements and a continuous covariate

Zhanfeng Wang, Tao Li, Liqun Xiao, Dongsheng Tu

摘要

Identification of a subgroup of patients who may be sensitive to a specific treatment is an important problem in precision medicine. This article considers the case where the treatment effect is assessed by longitudinal measurements, such as quality of life scores assessed over the duration of a clinical trial, and the subset is determined by a continuous baseline covariate, such as age and expression level of a biomarker. Recently, a linear mixed threshold regression model has been proposed but it assumes the longitudinal measurements are normally distributed. In many applications, longitudinal measurements, such as quality of life data obtained from answers to questions on a Likert scale, may be restricted in a fixed interval because of the floor and ceiling effects and, therefore, may be skewed. In this article, a threshold longitudinal Tobit quantile regression model is proposed and a computational approach based on alternating direction method of multipliers algorithm is developed for the estimation of parameters in the model. In addition, a random weighting method is employed to estimate the variances of the parameter estimators. The proposed procedures are evaluated through simulation studies and applications to the data from clinical trials.

JRSSB Causal Inference Testing & Uncertainty · 发表于 2023-08-19

Randomisation inference beyond the sharp null: bounded null hypotheses and quantiles of individual treatment effects

Devin Caughey, Allan Dafoe, Xinran Li, Luke Miratrix

摘要

Randomisation inference (RI) is typically interpreted as testing Fisher’s ‘sharp’ null hypothesis that all unit-level effects are exactly zero. This hypothesis is often criticised as restrictive and implausible, making its rejection scientifically uninteresting. We show, however, that many randomisation tests are also valid for a ‘bounded’ null hypothesis under which the unit-level effects are all non-positive (or all non-negative) but are otherwise heterogeneous. In addition to being more plausible a priori, bounded nulls are closely related to substantively important concepts such as monotonicity and Pareto efficiency. Reinterpreting RI in this way expands the range of inferences possible in this framework. We show that exact confidence intervals for the maximum (or minimum) unit-level effect can be obtained by inverting tests for a sequence of bounded nulls. We also generalise RI to cover inference for quantiles of the individual effect distribution as well as for the proportion of individual effects larger (or smaller) than a given threshold. The proposed confidence intervals for all effect quantiles are simultaneously valid, in the sense that no correction for multiple analyses is required. In sum, our reinterpretation and generalisation provide a broader justification for randomisation tests and a basis for exact non-parametric inference for effect quantiles.

SMMR Clinical Trials Optimization & Learning Theory Bayesian Methods · 发表于 2023-08-18

Local continual reassessment methods for dose finding and optimization in drug-combination trials

Jingyi Zhang, Fangrong Yan, Nolan A Wages, Ruitao Lin

摘要

Due to the limited sample size and large dose exploration space, obtaining a desirable dose combination is a challenging task in the early development of combination treatments for cancer patients. Most existing designs for optimizing the dose combination are model-based, requiring significant efforts to elicit parameters or prior distributions. Model-based designs also rely on intensive model calibration and may yield unstable performance in the case of model misspecification or sparse data. We propose to employ local, underparameterized models for dose exploration to reduce the hurdle of model calibration and enhance the design robustness. Building upon the framework of the partial ordering continual reassessment method, we develop local data-based continual reassessment method designs for identifying the maximum tolerated dose combination, using toxicity only, and the optimal biological dose combination, using both toxicity and efficacy, respectively. The local data-based continual reassessment method designs only model the local data from neighboring dose combinations. Therefore, they are flexible in estimating the local space and circumventing unstable characterization of the entire dose-exploration surface. Our simulation studies show that our approach has competitive performance compared to widely used methods for finding maximum tolerated dose combination, and it has advantages over existing model-based methods for optimizing optimal biological dose combination.

Biometrics Other · 发表于 2023-08-18

Generating Designs for Comparative Experiments with Two Blocking Factors

Nha Vo-Thanh, Hans-Peter Piepho

摘要

Often, comparative experiments involve a single treatment factor and two blocking factors, for example, augmented row–column, two-phase, and incomplete row–column experiments. These experiments are widely used in agriculture. Finding good designs for these experiments is a major challenge when the number of treatments is large and the blocking structure is complex. In this paper, we first propose a new search algorithm that is combined with efficient update formulae, so that optimal designs with two blocking factors can be found within a reasonable time. Second, we compare augmented row–column designs generated with our new method to those obtained from CycDesigN, DiGGer, and the OPTEX procedure of SAS in terms of computing times as well as the quality of solutions. Third, we illustrate our proposed approach with four applications. We show an example where our efficient update formulae work while existing update formulae cannot be applied, and we use our search framework to generate augmented row–column, two-phase, and incomplete row–column designs. We end the paper with a conclusion along with suggestions for potential applications.

JRSSB Other · 发表于 2023-08-17

Maxway CRT: improving the robustness of the model-X inference

Shuangning Li, Molei Liu

摘要

The model-X conditional randomisation test (CRT) is a flexible and powerful testing procedure for testing the hypothesis X⫫Y∣Z. However, it requires perfect knowledge of X∣Z and may lose its validity when there is an error in modelling X∣Z. This problem is even more severe when Z is of high dimensionality. In response to this, we propose the Maxway CRT, which learns the distribution of Y∣Z and uses it to calibrate the resampling distribution of X to gain robustness to the error in modelling X. We prove that the type-I error inflation of the Maxway CRT can be controlled by the learning error for a low-dimensional adjusting model plus the product of learning errors for X∣Z and Y∣Z, interpreted as an ‘almost doubly robust’ property. Based on this, we develop implementing algorithms of the Maxway CRT in practical scenarios including (surrogate-assisted) semi-supervised learning (SA-SSL) and transfer learning (TL). Through simulations, we demonstrate that the Maxway CRT achieves significantly better type-I error control than existing model-X inference approaches while preserving similar powers. Finally, we apply our methodology to two real examples of SA-SSL and TL.

SMMR Clinical Trials · 发表于 2023-08-17

Does it decay? Obtaining decaying correlation parameter values from previously analysed cluster randomised trials

Jessica Kasza, Rhys Bowden, Yongdong Ouyang, Monica Taljaard, Andrew B Forbes

摘要

A frequently applied assumption in the analysis of data from cluster randomised trials is that the outcomes from all participants within a cluster are equally correlated. That is, the intracluster correlation, which describes the degree of dependence between outcomes from participants in the same cluster, is the same for each pair of participants in a cluster. However, recent work has discussed the importance of allowing for this correlation to decay as the time between the measurement of participants in a cluster increases. Incorrect omission of such a decay can lead to under-powered studies, and confidence intervals for estimated treatment effects can be too narrow or too wide, depending on the characteristics of the design. When planning studies, researchers often rely on previously reported analyses of trials to inform their choice of intracluster correlation. However, most reported analyses of clustered data do not incorporate a correlation decay. Thus, often all that is available are estimates of intracluster correlations obtained under the potentially incorrect assumption of no decay. In this article, we show that it is possible to use intracluster correlation values obtained from models that incorrectly omit a decay to inform plausible choices of decaying correlations. Our focus is on intracluster correlation estimates for continuous outcomes obtained by fitting linear mixed models with exchangeable or block-exchangeable correlation structures. We describe how plausible values for decaying correlations may be obtained given these estimated intracluster correlations. An online app is presented that allows users to obtain plausible values of the decay, which can be used at the trial planning stage to assess the sensitivity of sample size and power calculations to decaying correlation structures.

SMMR Functional Data · 发表于 2023-08-17

Compositional functional regression and isotemporal substitution analysis: Methods and application in time-use epidemiology

Paulína Jašková, Javier Palarea-Albaladejo, Aleš Gába, Dorothea Dumuid, Željko Pedišić, Jana Pelclová, Karel Hron

摘要

The distribution of time that people spend in physical activity of various intensities has important health implications. Physical activity (commonly categorised by the intensity into light, moderate and vigorous physical activity), sedentary behaviour and sleep, should not be analysed separately, because they are parts of a time-use composition with a natural constraint of [Formula: see text] h/day. To find out how are relative reallocations of time between physical activity of various intensities associated with health, herewith we describe compositional scalar-on-function regression and a newly developed compositional functional isotemporal substitution analysis. Physical activity intensity data can be considered as probability density functions, which better reflects the continuous character of their measurement using accelerometers. These probability density functions are characterised by specific properties, such as scale invariance and relative scale, and they are geometrically represented using Bayes spaces with the Hilbert space structure. This makes possible to process them using standard methods of functional data analysis in the [Formula: see text] space, via centred logratio (clr) transformation. The scalar-on-function regression with clr transformation of the explanatory probability density functions and compositional functional isotemporal substitution analysis were applied to a dataset from a cross-sectional study on adiposity conducted among school-aged children in the Czech Republic. Theoretical reallocations of time to physical activity of higher intensities were found to be associated with larger and more progressive expected decreases in adiposity. We obtained a detailed insight into the dose–response relationship between physical activity intensity and adiposity, which was enabled by using the compositional functional approach.

SMMR Other · 发表于 2023-08-17

Approaches to risk ratio estimation in a regression discontinuity design: Application to the prescription of statins for cholesterol reduction in UK primary care

Mariam O Adeleke, Aidan G O’Keeffe, Gianluca Baio

摘要

In recent years regression discontinuity designs have been used increasingly for the estimation of treatment effects in observational medical data where a rule-based decision to apply treatment is taken using a continuous assignment variable. Most regression discontinuity design applications have focused on effect estimation where the outcome of interest is continuous, with scenarios with binary outcomes receiving less attention, despite their ubiquity in medical studies. In this work, we develop an approach to estimation of the risk ratio in a fuzzy regression discontinuity design (where treatment is not always strictly applied according to the decision rule), derived using common regression discontinuity design assumptions. This method compares favourably to other risk ratio estimation approaches: the established Wald estimator and a risk ratio estimate from a multiplicative structural mean model, with promising results from extensive simulation studies. A demonstration and further comparison are made using a real example to evaluate the effect of statins (where a statin prescription is made based on a patient’s 10-year cardiovascular disease risk score) on low-density lipoprotein cholesterol reduction in UK Primary Care.

Biometrics Longitudinal Data · 发表于 2023-08-16

How to Analyze Continuous and Discrete Repeated Measures in Small-Sample Cross-Over Trials?

Johan Verbeeck, Martin Geroldinger, Konstantin Thiel, Andrew Craig Hooker, Sebastian Ueckert, Mats Karlsson, Arne Cornelius Bathke, Johann Wolfgang Bauer, Geert Molenberghs, Georg Zimmermann

摘要

To optimize the use of data from a small number of subjects in rare disease trials, an at first sight advantageous design is the repeated measures cross-over design. However, it is unclear how these within-treatment period and within-subject clustered data are best analyzed in small-sample trials. In a real-data simulation study based upon a recent epidermolysis bullosa simplex trial using this design, we compare non-parametric marginal models, generalized pairwise comparison models, GEE-type models and parametric model averaging for both repeated binary and count data. The recommendation of which methodology to use in rare disease trials with a repeated measures cross-over design depends on the type of outcome and the number of time points the treatment has an effect on. The non-parametric marginal model testing the treatment–time-interaction effect is suitable for detecting between group differences in the shapes of the longitudinal profiles. For binary outcomes with the treatment effect on a single time point, the parametric model averaging method is recommended, while in the other cases the unmatched generalized pairwise comparison methodology is recommended. Both provide an easily interpretable effect size measure, and do not require exclusion of periods or subjects due to incompleteness.

SiM Survival Analysis Testing & Uncertainty · 发表于 2023-08-14

Confidence intervals for the Cox model test error from cross‐validation

Min Woo Sun, Robert Tibshirani

摘要

Summary: Cross‐validation (CV) is one of the most widely used techniques in statistical learning for estimating the test error of a model, but its behavior is not yet fully understood. It has been shown that standard confidence intervals for test error using estimates from CV may have coverage below nominal levels. This phenomenon occurs because each sample is used in both the training and testing procedures during CV and as a result, the CV estimates of the errors become correlated. Without accounting for this correlation, the estimate of the variance is smaller than it should be. One way to mitigate this issue is by estimating the mean squared error of the prediction error instead using nested CV. This approach has been shown to achieve superior coverage compared to intervals derived from standard CV. In this work, we generalize the nested CV idea to the Cox proportional hazards model and explore various choices of test error for this setting.

SiM Longitudinal Data Testing & Uncertainty Latent Variables & Mixtures · 发表于 2023-08-14

Clustering of trajectories with mixed effects classification model: Inference taking into account classification uncertainties

Charlotte Dugourd, Amna Abichou‐Klich, René Ecochard, Fabien Subtil

摘要

Classifying patient biomarker trajectories into groups has become frequent in clinical research. Mixed effects classification models can be used to model the heterogeneity of longitudinal data. The estimated parameters of typical trajectories and the partition can be provided by the classification version of the expectation maximization algorithm, named CEM. However, the variance of the parameter estimates obtained underestimates the true variance because classification uncertainties are not taken into account. This article takes into account these uncertainties by using the stochastic EM algorithm (SEM), a stochastic version of the CEM algorithm, after convergence of the CEM algorithm. The simulations showed correct coverage probabilities of the 95% confidence intervals (close to 95% except for scenarios with high bias in typical trajectories). The method was applied on a trial, called low‐cyclo, that compared the effects of low vs standard cyclosporine A doses on creatinine levels after cardiac transplantation. It identified groups of patients for whom low‐dose cyclosporine may be relevant, but with high uncertainty on the dose‐effect estimate.

SiM Missing Data & Measurement Error Bayesian Methods Clinical Trials · 发表于 2023-08-13

Simple Bayesian models for missing binary outcomes in randomized controlled trials

Adam Kaplan, David Nelson

摘要

Missing outcomes are commonly encountered in randomized controlled trials (RCT) involving human subjects and present a risk for substantial bias in the results of a complete case analysis. While response rates for RCTs are typically high there is no agreed upon universal threshold under which the amount of missing data is deemed to not be a threat to inference. We focus here on binary outcomes that are possibly missing not at random, that is, the value of the outcome influences its possibility of being observed. Salient information that can assist in addressing these missing outcomes in such situations is the anticipated response rate in each study arm; these can often be anticipated based on prior research in similar populations using similar designs and outcomes. Further, in some areas of human subjects research, we are often confident or we suspect that response rates among RCT participants with successful treatment outcomes will be at least as great as those among participants without successful treatment outcomes. In other settings we may suspect the opposite relationship. This direction of the differential response between those with successful and unsuccessful outcomes can further aid in addressing the missing outcomes. We present simple Bayesian pattern‐mixture models that incorporate this information on response rates to analyze the relationship between a binary outcome and an intervention while addressing the missing outcomes. We assess the performance of this method in simulation studies and apply this method to the results of an RCT of a smoking abstinence intervention.

SiM Missing Data & Measurement Error Nonparametric & Semiparametric Survival Analysis · 发表于 2023-08-13

Semiparametric probit regression model with misclassified current status data

Lijun Fang, Shuwei Li, Liuquan Sun, Xinyuan Song

摘要

Current status data arise when each subject under study is examined only once at an observation time, and one only knows the failure status of the event of interest at the observation time rather than the exact failure time. Moreover, the obtained failure status is frequently subject to misclassification due to imperfect tests, yielding misclassified current status data. This article conducts regression analysis of such data with the semiparametric probit model, which serves as an important alternative to existing semiparametric models and has recently received considerable attention in failure time data analysis. We consider the nonparametric maximum likelihood estimation and develop an expectation‐maximization (EM) algorithm by incorporating the generalized pool‐adjacent‐violators (PAV) algorithm to maximize the intractable likelihood function. The resulting estimators of regression parameters are shown to be consistent, asymptotically normal, and semiparametrically efficient. Furthermore, the numerical results in simulation studies indicate that the proposed method performs satisfactorily in finite samples and outperforms the naive method that ignores misclassification. We then apply the proposed method to a real dataset on chlamydia infection.

SMMR Survival Analysis Spatial & Time Series · 发表于 2023-08-10

Survival analysis with a random change-point

Chun Yin Lee, Kin Yau Wong

摘要

Contemporary works in change-point survival models mainly focus on an unknown universal change-point shared by the whole study population. However, in some situations, the change-point is plausibly individual-specific, such as when it corresponds to the telomere length or menopausal age. Also, maximum-likelihood-based inference for the fixed change-point parameter is notoriously complicated. The asymptotic distribution of the maximum-likelihood estimator is non-standard, and computationally intensive bootstrap techniques are commonly used to retrieve its sampling distribution. This article is motivated by a breast cancer study, where the disease-free survival time of the patients is postulated to be regulated by the menopausal age, which is unobserved. As menopausal age varies across patients, a fixed change-point survival model may be inadequate. Therefore, we propose a novel proportional hazards model with a random change-point. We develop a nonparametric maximum-likelihood estimation approach and devise a stable expectation–maximization algorithm to compute the estimators. Because the model is regular, we employ conventional likelihood theory for inference based on the asymptotic normality of the Euclidean parameter estimators, and the variance of the asymptotic distribution can be consistently estimated by a profile-likelihood approach. A simulation study demonstrates the satisfactory finite-sample performance of the proposed methods, which yield small bias and proper coverage probabilities. The methods are applied to the motivating breast cancer study.

Biometrics Causal Inference · 发表于 2023-08-10

A Second Evidence Factor for a Second Control Group

Paul R. Rosenbaum

摘要

In an observational study of the effects caused by a treatment, a second control group is used in an effort to detect bias from unmeasured covariates, and the investigator is content if no evidence of bias is found. This strategy is not entirely satisfactory: two control groups may differ significantly, yet the difference may be too small to invalidate inferences about the treatment, or the control groups may not differ yet nonetheless fail to provide a tangible strengthening of the evidence of a treatment effect. Is a firmer conclusion possible? Is there a way to analyze a second control group such that the data might report measurably strengthened evidence of cause and effect, that is, insensitivity to larger unmeasured biases? Evidence factor analyses are not commonly used with a second control group: most analyses compare the treated group to each control group, but analyses of that kind are partially redundant; so, they do not constitute evidence factors. An alternative analysis is proposed here, one that does yield two evidence factors, and with a carefully designed test statistic, is capable of extracting strong evidence from the second factor. The new technical work here concerns the development of a test statistic with high design sensitivity and high Bahadur efficiency in a sensitivity analysis for the second factor. A study of binge drinking as a cause of high blood pressure is used as an illustration.

Biometrics Survival Analysis · 发表于 2023-08-10

A Proportional Incidence Rate Model for Aggregated Data to Study the Vaccine Effectiveness Against COVID-19 Hospital and ICU Admissions

Ping Yan, Muhammad Abu Shadeque Mullah, Ashleigh Tuite

摘要

We develop a proportional incidence model that estimates vaccine effectiveness (VE) at the population level using conditional likelihood for aggregated data. Our model assumes that the population counts of clinical outcomes for an infectious disease arise from a superposition of Poisson processes with different vaccination statuses. The intensity function in the model is calculated as the product of per capita incidence rate and the at-risk population size, both of which are time-dependent. We formulate a log-linear regression model with respect to the relative risk, defined as the ratio between the per capita incidence rates of vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals. In the regression analysis, we treat the baseline incidence rate as a nuisance parameter, similar to the Cox proportional hazard model in survival analysis. We then apply the proposed models and methods to age-stratified weekly counts of COVID-19–related hospital and ICU admissions among adults in Ontario, Canada. The data spanned from 2021 to February 2022, encompassing the Omicron era and the rollout of booster vaccine doses. We also discuss the limitations and confounding effects while advocating for the necessity of more comprehensive and up-to-date individual-level data that document the clinical outcomes and measure potential confounders.

SMMR Survival Analysis Clinical Trials · 发表于 2023-08-09

Restricted mean survival time to estimate an intervention effect in a cluster randomized trial

Floriane Le Vilain–Abraham, Elsa Tavernier, Etienne Dantan, Solène Desmée, Agnès Caille

摘要

For time-to-event outcomes, the difference in restricted mean survival time is a measure of the intervention effect, an alternative to the hazard ratio, corresponding to the expected survival duration gain due to the intervention up to a predefined time t*. We extended two existing approaches of restricted mean survival time estimation for independent data to clustered data in the framework of cluster randomized trials: one based on the direct integration of Kaplan-Meier curves and the other based on pseudo-values regression. Then, we conducted a simulation study to assess and compare the statistical performance of the proposed methods, varying the number and size of clusters, the degree of clustering, and the magnitude of the intervention effect under proportional and non-proportional hazards assumption. We found that the extended methods well estimated the variance and controlled the type I error if there was a sufficient number of clusters (≥ 50) under both proportional and non-proportional hazards assumption. For cluster randomized trials with a limited number of clusters (< 50), a permutation test for pseudo-values regression was implemented and corrected the type I error. We also provided a procedure to estimate permutation-based confidence intervals which produced adequate coverage. All the extended methods performed similarly, but the pseudo-values regression offered the possibility to adjust for covariates. Finally, we illustrated each considered method with a cluster randomized trial evaluating the effectiveness of an asthma-control education program.

SMMR Causal Inference Survival Analysis · 发表于 2023-08-09

Propensity score weighting methods for causal subgroup analysis with time-to-event outcomes

Siyun Yang, Ruiwen Zhou, Fan Li, Laine E Thomas

摘要

Evaluating causal effects of an intervention in pre-specified subgroups is a standard goal in comparative effectiveness research. Despite recent advancements in causal subgroup analysis, research on time-to-event outcomes has been lacking. This article investigates the propensity score weighting method for causal subgroup survival analysis. We introduce two causal estimands, the subgroup marginal hazard ratio and subgroup restricted average causal effect, and provide corresponding propensity score weighting estimators. We analytically established that the bias of subgroup-restricted average causal effect is determined by subgroup covariate balance. Using extensive simulations, we compare the performance of various combinations of propensity score models (logistic regression, random forests, least absolute shrinkage and selection operator, and generalized boosted models) and weighting schemes (inverse probability weighting, and overlap weighting) for estimating the causal estimands. We find that the logistic model with subgroup-covariate interactions selected by least absolute shrinkage and selection operator consistently outperforms other propensity score models. Also, overlap weighting generally outperforms inverse probability weighting in terms of balance, bias and variance, and the advantage is particularly pronounced in small subgroups and/or in the presence of poor overlap. We applied the methods to the observational Comparing Options for Management: PAtient-centered REsults for Uterine Fibroids study to evaluate the causal effects of myomectomy versus hysterectomy on the time to disease recurrence in a number of pre-specified subgroups of patients with uterine fibroids.

SMMR Other · 发表于 2023-08-09

Missing values and inconclusive results in diagnostic studies – A scoping review of methods

Katharina Stahlmann, Johannes B Reitsma, Antonia Zapf

摘要

Most diagnostic studies exclude missing values and inconclusive results from the analysis or apply simple methods resulting in biased accuracy estimates. This may be due to the lack of availability or awareness of appropriate methods. This scoping review aimed to provide an overview of strategies to handle missing values and inconclusive results in the reference standard or index test in diagnostic accuracy studies. Conducting a systematic literature search in MEDLINE, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science, we could identify many articles proposing methods for addressing missing values in the reference standard. There are also several articles describing methods regarding missing values or inconclusive results in the index test. The latter encompass imputation, frequentist and Bayesian likelihood, model-based, and latent class methods. While methods for missing values in the reference standard are regularly applied in practice, this is not true for methods addressing missing values and inconclusive results in the index test. Our comprehensive overview and description of available methods may raise further awareness of these methods and will enhance their application. Future research is needed to compare the performance of these methods under different conditions to give valid and robust recommendations for their usage in various diagnostic accuracy research scenarios.

SiM Spatial & Time Series Bayesian Methods · 发表于 2023-08-09

Forecasting emergency department waiting time using a state space representation

Kelly Trinh, Andrew Staib, Anton Pak

摘要

The provision of waiting time information in emergency departments (ED) has become an increasingly popular practice due to its positive impact on patient experience and ED demand management. However, little scientific attention has been given to the quality and quantity of waiting time information presented to patients. To improve both aspects, we propose a set of state space models with flexible error structures to forecast ED waiting time for low acuity patients. Our approach utilizes a Bayesian framework to generate uncertainties associated with the forecasts. We find that the state‐space models with flexible error structures significantly improve forecast accuracy of ED waiting time compared to the benchmark, which is the rolling average model. Specifically, incorporating time‐varying and correlated error terms reduces the root mean squared errors of the benchmark by 10%. Furthermore, treating zero‐recorded waiting times as unobserved values improves forecast performance. Our proposed model has the ability to provide patient‐centric waiting time information. By offering more accurate and informative waiting time information, our model can help patients make better informed decisions and ultimately enhance their ED experience.

SMMR Survival Analysis Nonparametric & Semiparametric · 发表于 2023-08-09

Bivariate copula regression models for semi-competing risks

Yinghui Wei, Małgorzata Wojtyś, Lexy Sorrell, Peter Rowe

摘要

Time-to-event semi-competing risk endpoints may be correlated when both events occur on the same individual. These events and the association between them may also be influenced by individual characteristics. In this article, we propose copula survival models to estimate hazard ratios of covariates on the non-terminal and terminal events, along with the effects of covariates on the association between the two events. We use the Normal, Clayton, Frank and Gumbel copulas to provide a variety of association structures between the non-terminal and terminal events. We apply the proposed methods to model semi-competing risks of graft failure and death for kidney transplant patients. We find that copula survival models perform better than the Cox proportional hazards model when estimating the non-terminal event hazard ratio of covariates. We also find that the inclusion of covariates in the association parameter of the copula models improves the estimation of the hazard ratios.

SiM Causal Inference Meta-Analysis & Data Integration · 发表于 2023-08-08

Federated causal inference in heterogeneous observational data

Ruoxuan Xiong, Allison Koenecke, Michael Powell, Zhu Shen, Joshua T. Vogelstein, Susan Athey

摘要

We are interested in estimating the effect of a treatment applied to individuals at multiple sites, where data is stored locally for each site. Due to privacy constraints, individual‐level data cannot be shared across sites; the sites may also have heterogeneous populations and treatment assignment mechanisms. Motivated by these considerations, we develop federated methods to draw inferences on the average treatment effects of combined data across sites. Our methods first compute summary statistics locally using propensity scores and then aggregate these statistics across sites to obtain point and variance estimators of average treatment effects. We show that these estimators are consistent and asymptotically normal. To achieve these asymptotic properties, we find that the aggregation schemes need to account for the heterogeneity in treatment assignments and in outcomes across sites. We demonstrate the validity of our federated methods through a comparative study of two large medical claims databases.

JRSSB Causal Inference · 发表于 2023-08-08

Debiased inference on heterogeneous quantile treatment effects with regression rank scores

Alexander Giessing, Jingshen Wang

摘要

Understanding treatment effect heterogeneity is vital to many scientific fields because the same treatment may affect different individuals differently. Quantile regression provides a natural framework for modelling such heterogeneity. We propose a new method for inference on heterogeneous quantile treatment effects (HQTE) in the presence of high-dimensional covariates. Our estimator combines an ℓ1-penalised regression adjustment with a quantile-specific bias correction scheme based on rank scores. We study the theoretical properties of this estimator, including weak convergence and semi-parametric efficiency of the estimated HQTE process. We illustrate the finite-sample performance of our approach through simulations and an empirical example, dealing with the differential effect of statin usage for lowering low-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels for the Alzheimer’s disease patients who participated in the UK Biobank study.

Biometrics Causal Inference Missing Data & Measurement Error Bayesian Methods · 发表于 2023-08-08

Bayesian Causal Inference for Observational Studies with Missingness in Covariates and Outcomes

Huaiyu Zang, Hang J. Kim, Bin Huang, Rhonda Szczesniak

摘要

Missing data are a pervasive issue in observational studies using electronic health records or patient registries. It presents unique challenges for statistical inference, especially causal inference. Inappropriately handling missing data in causal inference could potentially bias causal estimation. Besides missing data problems, observational health data structures typically have mixed-type variables - continuous and categorical covariates - whose joint distribution is often too complex to be modeled by simple parametric models. The existence of missing values in covariates and outcomes makes the causal inference even more challenging, while most standard causal inference approaches assume fully observed data or start their works after imputing missing values in a separate preprocessing stage. To address these problems, we introduce a Bayesian nonparametric causal model to estimate causal effects with missing data. The proposed approach can simultaneously impute missing values, account for multiple outcomes, and estimate causal effects under the potential outcomes framework. We provide three simulation studies to show the performance of our proposed method under complicated data settings whose features are similar to our case studies. For example, Simulation Study 3 assumes the case where missing values exist in both outcomes and covariates. Two case studies were conducted applying our method to evaluate the comparative effectiveness of treatments for chronic disease management in juvenile idiopathic arthritis and cystic fibrosis.

SiM Other · 发表于 2023-08-07

Rank intraclass correlation for clustered data

Shengxin Tu, Chun Li, Donglin Zeng, Bryan E. Shepherd

摘要

Clustered data are common in biomedical research. Observations in the same cluster are often more similar to each other than to observations from other clusters. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), first introduced by R. A. Fisher, is frequently used to measure this degree of similarity. However, the ICC is sensitive to extreme values and skewed distributions, and depends on the scale of the data. It is also not applicable to ordered categorical data. We define the rank ICC as a natural extension of Fisher's ICC to the rank scale, and describe its corresponding population parameter. The rank ICC is simply interpreted as the rank correlation between a random pair of observations from the same cluster. We also extend the definition when the underlying distribution has more than two hierarchies. We describe estimation and inference procedures, show the asymptotic properties of our estimator, conduct simulations to evaluate its performance, and illustrate our method in three real data examples with skewed data, count data, and three‐level ordered categorical data.

Biometrika Nonparametric & Semiparametric Optimization & Learning Theory · 发表于 2023-08-07

Kernel interpolation generalizes poorly

Yicheng Li, Haobo Zhang, Qian Lin

摘要

Summary: One of the most interesting problems in the recent renaissance of the studies in kernel regression might be whether kernel interpolation can generalize well, since it may help us understand the ‘benign overfitting phenomenon’ reported in the literature on deep networks. In this paper, under mild conditions, we show that, for any ε&gt;0, the generalization error of kernel interpolation is lower bounded by Ω(n−ε). In other words, the kernel interpolation generalizes poorly for a large class of kernels. As a direct corollary, we can show that overfitted wide neural networks defined on the sphere generalize poorly.

SiM Causal Inference · 发表于 2023-08-07

Instrumental variable analysis for cost outcome: Application to the effect of primary care visit on medical cost among low‐income adults

Dexiang Gao, Junxiao Hu, Cathy J. Bradley, Fan Yang

摘要

Medical cost data often consist of zero values as well as extremely right‐skewed positive values. A two‐part model is a popular choice for analyzing medical cost data, where the first part models the probability of a positive cost using logistic regression and the second part models the positive cost using a lognormal or Gamma distribution. To address the unmeasured confounding in studies on cost outcome under two‐part models, two instrumental variable (IV) methods, two‐stage residual inclusion (2SRI) and two‐stage prediction substitution (2SPS) are widely applied. However, previous literature demonstrated that both the 2SRI and the 2SPS could fail to consistently estimate the causal effect among compliers under standard IV assumptions for binary and survival outcomes. Our simulation studies confirmed that it continued to be the case for a two‐part model, which is another nonlinear model. In this article, we develop a model‐based IV approach, Instrumental Variable with Two‐Part model (IV2P), to obtain a consistent estimate of the causal effect among compliers for cost outcome under standard IV assumptions. In addition, we develop sensitivity analysis approaches to allow the evaluation of the sensitivity of the causal conclusions to potential quantified violations of the exclusion restriction assumption and the randomization of IV assumption. We apply our method to a randomized cash incentive study to evaluate the effect of a primary care visit on medical cost among low‐income adults newly covered by a primary care program.

JASA Meta-Analysis & Data Integration High-Dimensional · 发表于 2023-08-04

Statistical Inference for Maximin Effects: Identifying Stable Associations across Multiple Studies

Zijian Guo

摘要

Integrative analysis of data from multiple sources is critical to making generalizable discoveries. Associations consistently observed across multiple source populations are more likely to be generalized to target populations with possible distributional shifts. In this paper, we model the heterogeneous multi-source data with multiple high-dimensional regressions and make inferences for the maximin effect (Meinshausen, Bühlmann, AoS, 43(4), 1801-1830). The maximin effect provides a measure of stable associations across multi-source data. A significant maximin effect indicates that a variable has commonly shared effects across multiple source populations, and these shared effects may be generalized to a broader set of target populations. There are challenges associated with inferring maximin effects because its point estimator can have a non-standard limiting distribution. We devise a novel sampling method to construct valid confidence intervals for maximin effects. The proposed confidence interval attains a parametric length. This sampling procedure and the related theoretical analysis are of independent interest for solving other non-standard inference problems. Using genetic data on yeast growth in multiple environments, we demonstrate that the genetic variants with significant maximin effects have generalizable effects under new environments. The proposed method is implemented in the R package Maximininfer available from CRAN. *(abstract via PubMed)*

JASA Genetics & Omics · 发表于 2023-08-04

Factor Augmented Inverse Regression and its Application to Microbiome Data Analysis

Daolin Pang, Hongyu Zhao, Tao Wang

摘要

We investigate the relationship between count data that inform the relative abundance of features of a composition, and factors that influence the composition. Our work is motivated from microbiome studies aiming to extract microbial signatures that are predictive of host phenotypes based on data collected from a group of individuals harboring radically different microbial communities. We introduce multinomial Factor Augmented Inverse Regression (FAIR) of the count vector onto response factors as a general framework for obtaining low-dimensional summaries of the count vector that preserve information relevant to the response. By augmenting known response factors with random latent factors, FAIR extends multinomial logistic regression to account for overdispersion and general correlations among counts. The projections of the count vector onto the loading vectors represent additional contribution, in addition to the projections that result from response factors. The method of maximum variational likelihood and a fast variational expectation-maximization algorithm are proposed for approximate inference based on variational approximation, and the asymptotic properties of the resulting estimator are derived. Moreover, a hybrid information criterion and a group-lasso penalized criterion are proposed for model selection. The effectiveness of FAIR is illustrated through simulations and application to a microbiome dataset. Supplementary materials for this article are available online. *(abstract via OpenAlex)*

Biometrika Survival Analysis Testing & Uncertainty · 发表于 2023-08-02

τ-censored weighted Benjamini–Hochberg procedures under independence

Haibing Zhao, Huijuan Zhou

摘要

In the field of multiple hypothesis testing, auxiliary information can be leveraged to enhance the efficiency of test procedures. A common way to make use of auxiliary information is by weighting p-values. However, when the weights are learned from data, controlling the finite-sample false discovery rate becomes challenging, and most existing weighted procedures only guarantee false discovery rate control in an asymptotic limit. In a recent study conducted by Ignatiadis & Huber (2021), a novel τ-censored weighted Benjamini–Hochberg procedure was proposed to control the finite-sample false discovery rate. The authors employed the cross-weighting approach to learn weights for the p-values. This approach randomly splits the data into several folds and constructs a weight for each p-value Pi using the p-values outside the fold containing Pi. Cross-weighting does not exploit the p-value information inside the fold and only balances the weights within each fold, which may result in a loss of power. In this article, we introduce two methods for constructing data-driven weights for τ-censored weighted Benjamini–Hochberg procedures under independence. They provide new insight into masking p-values to prevent overfitting in multiple testing. The first method utilizes a leave-one-out technique, where all but one of the p-values are used to learn a weight for each p-value. This technique masks the information of a p-value in its weight by calculating the infimum of the weight with respect to the p-value. The second method uses partial information from each p-value to construct weights and utilizes the conditional distributions of the null p-values to establish false discovery rate control. Additionally, we propose two methods for estimating the null proportion and demonstrate how to integrate null-proportion adaptivity into the proposed weights to improve power.

SiM Causal Inference Nonparametric & Semiparametric Machine Learning · 发表于 2023-08-02

Parametric and nonparametric propensity score estimation in multilevel observational studies

Marie Salditt, Steffen Nestler

摘要

There has been growing interest in using nonparametric machine learning approaches for propensity score estimation in order to foster robustness against misspecification of the propensity score model. However, the vast majority of studies focused on single‐level data settings, and research on nonparametric propensity score estimation in clustered data settings is scarce. In this article, we extend existing research by describing a general algorithm for incorporating random effects into a machine learning model, which we implemented for generalized boosted modeling (GBM). In a simulation study, we investigated the performance of logistic regression, GBM, and Bayesian additive regression trees for inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPW) when the data are clustered, the treatment exposure mechanism is nonlinear, and unmeasured cluster‐level confounding is present. For each approach, we compared fixed and random effects propensity score models to single‐level models and evaluated their use in both marginal and clustered IPW. We additionally investigated the performance of the standard Super Learner and the balance Super Learner. The results showed that when there was no unmeasured confounding, logistic regression resulted in moderate bias in both marginal and clustered IPW, whereas the nonparametric approaches were unbiased. In presence of cluster‐level confounding, fixed and random effects models greatly reduced bias compared to single‐level models in marginal IPW, with fixed effects GBM and fixed effects logistic regression performing best. Finally, clustered IPW was overall preferable to marginal IPW and the balance Super Learner outperformed the standard Super Learner, though neither worked as well as their best candidate model.

Biometrics Other · 发表于 2023-08-02

Optimal test Procedures for Multiple Hypotheses Controlling the Familywise Expected Loss

Willi Maurer, Frank Bretz, Xiaolei Xun

摘要

We consider the problem of testing multiple null hypotheses, where a decision to reject or retain must be made for each one and embedding incorrect decisions into a real-life context may inflict different losses. We argue that traditional methods controlling the Type I error rate may be too restrictive in this situation and that the standard familywise error rate may not be appropriate. Using a decision-theoretic approach, we define suitable loss functions for a given decision rule, where incorrect decisions can be treated unequally by assigning different loss values. Taking expectation with respect to the sampling distribution of the data allows us to control the familywise expected loss instead of the conventional familywise error rate. Different loss functions can be adopted, and we search for decision rules that satisfy certain optimality criteria within a broad class of decision rules for which the expected loss is bounded by a fixed threshold under any parameter configuration. We illustrate the methods with the problem of establishing efficacy of a new medicinal treatment in non-overlapping subgroups of patients.

JASA High-Dimensional Networks & Graphs · 发表于 2023-08-02

On the Estimation of the Number of Communities for Sparse Networks

Neil Hwang, Jiarui Xu, Shirshendu Chatterjee, Sharmodeep Bhattacharyya

摘要

Among the nonparametric methods of estimating the number of communities (K) in a community detection problem, methods based on the spectrum of the Bethe Hessian matrices (Hζ with the scalar parameter ζ) have garnered much popularity for their simplicity, computational efficiency, and robustness to the sparsity of data. For certain heuristic choices of ζ, such methods have been shown to be consistent for networks with N nodes with a common expected degree of ω( log N). In this article, we obtain several finite sample results to show that if the input network is generated from either stochastic block models or degree-corrected block models, and if ζ is chosen from a certain interval, then the associated spectral methods based on Hζ is consistent for estimating K for the sub-logarithmic sparse regime, when the expected maximum degree is both o( log N) and ω(1), under some mild conditions even in the situation when K increases with N. We also propose a method to estimate the aforementioned interval empirically, which enables us to develop a consistent K estimation procedure in the sparse regime. We evaluate the performance of the resulting estimation procedure theoretically, also empirically through extensive simulation studies and application to a comprehensive collection of real-world network data. Supplementary materials for this article are available online. *(abstract via OpenAlex)*

Biometrics Causal Inference · 发表于 2023-08-02

Efficient Algorithms for Building Representative Matched Pairs with Enhanced Generalizability

Bo Zhang

摘要

Many recent efforts center on assessing the ability of real-world evidence (RWE) generated from non-randomized, observational data to produce results compatible with those from randomized controlled trials (RCTs). One noticeable endeavor is the RCT DUPLICATE initiative. To better reconcile findings from an observational study and an RCT, or two observational studies based on different databases, it is desirable to eliminate differences between study populations. We outline an efficient, network-flow-based statistical matching algorithm that designs well-matched pairs from observational data that resemble the covariate distributions of a target population, for instance, the target-RCT-eligible population in the RCT DUPLICATE initiative studies or a generic population of scientific interest. We demonstrate the usefulness of the method by revisiting the inconsistency regarding a cardioprotective effect of the hormone replacement therapy (HRT) in the Women's Health Initiative (WHI) clinical trial and corresponding observational study. We found that the discrepancy between the trial and observational study persisted in a design that adjusted for the difference in study populations' cardiovascular risk profile, but seemed to disappear in a study design that further adjusted for the difference in HRT initiation age and previous estrogen-plus-progestin use. The proposed method is integrated into the R package match2C.

AoS High-Dimensional · 发表于 2023-08-01

Universality of regularized regression estimators in high dimensions

Qiyang Han, Yandi Shen

摘要

The Convex Gaussian Min–Max Theorem (CGMT) has emerged as a prominent theoretical tool for analyzing the precise stochastic behavior of various statistical estimators in the so-called high-dimensional proportional regime, where the sample size and the signal dimension are of the same order. However, a well-recognized limitation of the existing CGMT machinery rests in its stringent requirement on the exact Gaussianity of the design matrix, therefore rendering the obtained precise high-dimensional asymptotics, largely a specific Gaussian theory in various important statistical models. This paper provides a structural universality framework for a broad class of regularized regression estimators that is particularly compatible with the CGMT machinery. Here, universality means that if a “structure” is satisfied by the regression estimator μˆG for a standard Gaussian design G, then it will also be satisfied by μˆA for a general non-Gaussian design A with independent entries. In particular, we show that with a good enough ℓ∞ bound for the regression estimator μˆA, any “structural property” that can be detected via the CGMT for μˆG also holds for μˆA under a general design A with independent entries. As a proof of concept, we demonstrate our new universality framework in three key examples of regularized regression estimators: the Ridge, Lasso and regularized robust regression estimators, where new universality properties of risk asymptotics and/or distributions of regression estimators and other related quantities are proved. As a major statistical implication of the Lasso universality results, we validate inference procedures using the degrees-of-freedom adjusted debiased Lasso under general design and error distributions. We also provide a counterexample, showing that universality properties for regularized regression estimators do not extend to general isotropic designs. The proof of our universality results relies on new comparison inequalities for the optimum of a broad class of cost functions and Gordon’s max–min (or min–max) costs, over arbitrary structure sets subject to ℓ∞ constraints. These results may be of independent interest and broader applicability.

AoS Other · 发表于 2023-08-01

Statistical inference on a changing extreme value dependence structure

Holger Drees

摘要

We analyze the extreme value dependence of independent, not necessarily identically distributed multivariate regularly varying random vectors. More specifically, we propose estimators of the spectral measure locally at some time point and of the spectral measures integrated over time. The uniform asymptotic normality of these estimators is proved under suitable nonparametric smoothness and regularity assumptions. We then use the process convergence of the integrated spectral measure to devise consistent tests for the null hypothesis that the spectral measure does not change over time.

AoS Testing & Uncertainty Networks & Graphs · 发表于 2023-08-01

Single index Fréchet regression

Satarupa Bhattacharjee, Hans-Georg Müller

摘要

Single index models provide an effective dimension reduction tool in regression, especially for high-dimensional data, by projecting a general multivariate predictor onto a direction vector. We propose a novel single-index model for regression models where metric space-valued random object responses are coupled with multivariate Euclidean predictors. The responses in this regression model include complex, non-Euclidean data, including covariance matrices, graph Laplacians of networks and univariate probability distribution functions, among other complex objects that lie in abstract metric spaces. While Fréchet regression has proved useful for modeling the conditional mean of such random objects given multivariate Euclidean vectors, it does not provide for regression parameters such as slopes or intercepts, since the metric space-valued responses are not amenable to linear operations. As a consequence, distributional results for Fréchet regression have been elusive. We show here that for the case of multivariate Euclidean predictors, the parameters that define a single index and projection vector can be used to substitute for the inherent absence of parameters in Fréchet regression. Specifically, we derive the asymptotic distribution of suitable estimates of these parameters, which then can be utilized to test linear hypotheses for the parameters, subject to an identifiability condition. Consistent estimation of the link function of the single index Fréchet regression model is obtained through local linear Fréchet regression. We demonstrate the finite sample performance of estimation and inference for the proposed single index Fréchet regression model through simulation studies, including the special cases where responses are probability distributions and graph adjacency matrices. The method is illustrated for resting-state functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) data from the ADNI study.

AoS Optimization & Learning Theory · 发表于 2023-08-01

Relaxing the i.i.d. assumption: Adaptively minimax optimal regret via root-entropic regularization

Blair Bilodeau, Jeffrey Negrea, Daniel M. Roy

摘要

We consider prediction with expert advice when data are generated from distributions varying arbitrarily within an unknown constraint set. This semi-adversarial setting includes (at the extremes) the classical i.i.d. setting, when the unknown constraint set is restricted to be a singleton, and the unconstrained adversarial setting, when the constraint set is the set of all distributions. The Hedge algorithm—long known to be minimax (rate) optimal in the adversarial regime—was recently shown to be simultaneously minimax optimal for i.i.d. data. In this work, we propose to relax the i.i.d. assumption by seeking adaptivity at all levels of a natural ordering on constraint sets. We provide matching upper and lower bounds on the minimax regret at all levels, show that Hedge with deterministic learning rates is suboptimal outside of the extremes and prove that one can adaptively obtain minimax regret at all levels. We achieve this optimal adaptivity using the follow-the-regularized-leader (FTRL) framework, with a novel adaptive regularization scheme that implicitly scales as the square root of the entropy of the current predictive distribution, rather than the entropy of the initial predictive distribution. Finally, we provide novel technical tools to study the statistical performance of FTRL along the semi-adversarial spectrum.

第 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 页